Statement
from Professor Martha C. Nussbaum, Ernst Freund Distinguished Service
Professor of Law and Ethics, University of Chicago:
I would like
to express my support for Chicago's recent enactment of the ordinance
to prohibit sale of foie gras within the city and my opposition to any
attempt to repeal this law. Foie gras cannot be produced without torturously
force-feeding birds and, thus, is by necessity the product of extreme
animal cruelty. At the same time, the so-called "delicacy" is
completely unnecessary for human health or well-being. By prohibiting
its sale, Chicago has taken a sensible and practical step towards ending
the support of, and motivation for, such cruelty by eliminating the market
for the product within the city. This is the type of regulation that Chicago
and other cities are accustomed to enacting in reference to a wide variety
of issues that impact the public good, including animal cruelty. It is
comparable to bans on the sale of products produced from endangered species
and the sale of dog or cat pelts, and is consistent with this city's civility
and ethics. Indeed, the elimination of support for practices that are
cruel to animals has long been accepted as a mainstream value of civilized
societies, which recognize not only the virtue of compassion towards animals,
but a duty to refrain from, inhibit, and punish acts that cause unnecessary
suffering. By passing this ordinance, Chicago gains status and respect
in the world community, and is known as a city that affirms the highest
ethical values. |